Reports of students
Question1 : have you ever faced any negative methods of punishment in your school ??
The best methods of punishment
1-giving the student prize if he do what the teacher ask him to do
2-make a school trips for the clever students
3-the teacher treat with the student as his friend
4-for bid the student from making the activities which he love if he don‘t dis plain
5-make special language of cover station between the teacher and the student
6-the teacher should make the student understand his mistake
7-the teacher should pay the student attention to his mistake
8- the teacher should make trips and prizes for the clever students
answer1: the teacher must punish the students by forbid them from the break and B.E
answer 2 :the teacher can punish the students by forbid them from
talking with the teacher until the student feel with his mistake and
apologize to his teacher
answer3 :the teacher can send to the student‘s parents to punish their sons
The worst ways:
* Hit the student in front of his colleagues (Sarah Jamal)
(Radwa Mahmoud) beating and making fun of him in front of colleagues Respondent
(1): The teacher us feel that we are in the Stone Age, it enters the
chapter in his hand a stick and (become) We have omitted, and if broken
or anything happens to her using the belt,, On one occasion entered the
teacher's classroom, and was in bad psychological state, one student
said to him: Please drink??!!
He refused the teacher and the student strike hard and deeply insulting Respondent
(2): the teacher is the source of fear and anxiety when the student,
at one point late to share 5 minutes, from what I hit, but the teacher
in front of the whole chapter and Ahanna. Another time we were in the
share of physical education and the teacher was showing us some new
exercises and chapter he makes do like him, there was a student can not
do exercises, and when he saw the teacher, had insulted the entire
chapter insults hurt their feelings Respondent
(3): Sometimes I feel that I am not in school, but I feel that I am
in prison, the teacher punishing us severely, and sometimes Ahenna be
for some unknown reason, or because of trivial
The consequences of negative punishment:
(Radwa Mahmoud) * Fear of isolation
* participate
* hates to receive information from the student teacher Fear of the
student teacher, making it the Hate article and share (Sarah Jamal)
* Escape from the quota, and sometimes from school
* stubbornness and lack of student response to the orders of
the teacher once again excellence * student violent manner with
colleagues, teachers, and cause psychological crises of the
student Respondent (1,2,3): the impact of this punishment is that the
teacher hates the student and the material and can also hates school and
this affects the psychological punishment is a bad student, and it is
always afraid of the
teacher.........................................................................................Consequences of positive punishment: * The student of form and improve his behavior (Radwa Mahmoud)
* stimulate the rest of the
fellows.........................................................Parking:
- (1) Name talibes: Ibtisam Ali Jalal, the first preparatory (junior
high school to two joint) income teacher chapter, was in a bad
psychological state, she said to him talibes: Drink as possible, but he
refused the teacher, student and hit hard and insulted her
(2) Student Name: Asim Khalid Ibrahim Faraj, a fifth primary
(school - Haramain lights) delayed students to share 5 minutes what was
the teacher, but the beat and humiliated in front of chapter strongly
(3) Student Name: Asim Khalid Ibrahim Faraj, a fifth primary (school
lights of the Two Holy) students were in the share of physical education
and the teacher show them some exercise, and there was a student can
not do aerobics, and when he saw the teacher, had insulted the chapter
completely insults hurt their feelings (4) The name of the student
teacher hit the student chapter for some reason
unknown........................................................................................Types
of punishment: the physical punishment: a severe beating by different
methods such as caning 2 - psychological punishment: it is through
insults and mockery and ridicule from student First, the negative ways
1 - Comparison destructive between pupils and praise the student
specific form of exaggeration, which may lead to the hatred of his
colleagues, his
2 - humiliation, which hurt the feelings of the student
3 - irony of the answer the student or his behavior in front of his
4 - beating Aalambrah or harmful
5 - Expulsion outside Chapter
6 - punishment of the student without the knowledge of the cause of punishment
7 - discount grades Reasons:
1 - teachers used on those roads in the wrong punishment
2 - the environment in which the teacher affect the choice of method of punishment
3 - lack of interest of the teacher and pupils to know their interests
Interviews of experts:
Dr. Abdullah Shawky "Under the Faculty of Education, Zagazig University"
Q 1: What are the reasons for punishment?
Punishment is a departure from the unwanted behavior is a violation
of everything natural and physical punishment is not punishment, I'm
not a supporter of the use of corporal punishment, but the moral and
psychological punishment is yielding positive results rather
thannegative.
Q 2: Why object to corporal punishment?
For there is no way to
configure the man a sound or a good citizen because there
are so-called suppressed feeling and subconsciousVijzn the
individual suffering from the beating inside it does not appear, but at
some point after adolescence, so he deals with those around him a kind
of violence because it is the result of breedingcumulative and
shows real violence which are raised upon the individual in any
position emotionally.
Q 3: What are the educational methods that can be used as alternatives?
Through the grades and admonition and by the rule
of spouse to spouse and
through facial gestures and simple hints and bind family school and
through the media, places of worship, advice and guidance.